Email marketing remains one of the most cost-effective ways to communicate with customers, but even the best-managed email lists suffer from subscriber inactivity over time. While it’s natural for some level of attrition to occur, neglecting dormant subscribers can harm your sender reputation, lower your open rates, and ultimately reduce ROI.
At Bigg, we help businesses transform their email marketing strategies to not only attract new subscribers but also re-engage those who’ve gone quiet. This article delves into the reasons subscribers become inactive, actionable steps to bring them back, and how to measure success. Let’s get started.
Why Do Subscribers Become Inactive?
Inactive subscribers aren’t always uninterested subscribers. Understanding the reasons behind their disengagement is critical to crafting an effective re-engagement strategy.
Irrelevant Content: Subscribers’ interests evolve, and if your content no longer resonates with them, they’ll stop opening your emails.
Email Frequency: Sending emails too frequently can overwhelm subscribers, while infrequent emails may cause them to forget about your brand altogether.
Inbox Clutter: Many people receive dozens – if not hundreds – of emails daily, meaning your messages might get lost in the noise.
Life Changes: Subscribers’ circumstances change; for example, they may no longer require your product or service, or they might have switched email addresses.
Strategies for Re-Engaging Dormant Subscribers
Re-engagement isn’t about begging your subscribers to return – it’s about reminding them of the value you provide. At Bigg, we’ve fine-tuned these strategies to make the process as effective as possible.
Step 1: Take Stock of Your Email List
Before diving into re-engagement, it’s time for a little spring cleaning. Start by identifying who’s gone quiet – subscribers who haven’t opened or interacted with your emails in 6–12 months are a good place to start. Group these people into a separate list so you can focus your reactivation efforts on them.
While you’re at it, tidy up your list. Get rid of invalid or hard-bounced email addresses that could be dragging down your sender reputation. A smaller, more accurate list isn’t just easier to manage – it’s also far more effective.
Finally, have a look at what’s worked in the past. Are certain types of content or offers more popular? What’s the common thread in your most successful campaigns? These insights will give you a strong foundation for your re-engagement efforts.
Step 2: Send a Personalised Re-Engagement Campaign
Let’s face it, nobody wants to feel like just another name on a list. If you’re trying to re-engage someone, your email campaigns need to feel personal and meaningful.
Kick things off with a subject line that grabs their attention. Phrases like “We Miss You!” or “Still Interested? Here’s Something Special” can pique curiosity and encourage a click. Inside, reintroduce yourself with a warm, friendly tone. Remind them why they signed up in the first place and highlight what they’ve been missing – whether that’s exclusive offers, insider tips, or just great content.
And don’t forget the incentive. A special discount, free resource, or sneak peek at something exciting can make all the difference. Most importantly, make it clear what you’d like them to do next. Whether it’s clicking a link, updating their preferences, or claiming an offer, your call to action (CTA) should be simple and easy to follow.
Step 3: Give Subscribers More Control
Sometimes people stop engaging because they feel bombarded, or because the content isn’t quite hitting the mark. To fix this, put the power back in their hands.
Set up a preferences centre where subscribers can tell you what they want to receive and how often. Maybe they’re only interested in updates about specific products, or they’d prefer emails less frequently. Giving them these options not only builds trust but also increases the chances they’ll stick around.
You could even include a quick survey in your email. Ask questions like, “What type of content would you like to see?” or “How can we improve your experience?” Not only does this show you care, but it also gives you valuable insights for future campaigns.
Step 4: Stay Consistent with Automation
Automation is your best friend when it comes to keeping re-engaged subscribers interested. Once someone interacts with your re-engagement email, follow up with a series of messages to nurture their renewed interest.
For example, you could send a “welcome back” email with a round-up of your latest updates. From there, use automation to send personalised content based on their activity – e.g. products they’ve browsed or links they’ve clicked. Birthdays, anniversaries, or even seasonal events are also great opportunities to send thoughtful messages that keep your brand top of mind.
Tools like Mailchimp or HubSpot make it easy to automate these processes without losing that personal touch.
Step 5: Try a Win-Back Campaign
If your initial re-engagement email doesn’t do the trick, don’t give up just yet. A win-back campaign is a last-ditch effort to reignite interest, and it’s worth a shot before you say goodbye.
In this email, it’s all about urgency. Use phrases like “This Could Be Our Last Email to You” or “Do You Still Want to Hear From Us?” to encourage them to make a decision. Sweeten the deal with an exclusive incentive, like a bigger discount or free delivery, and make it crystal clear how they can stay on your list.
That said, it’s equally important to respect their choice if they don’t want to stay subscribed. Including an easy-to-find unsubscribe link helps maintain trust and keeps your list full of people who actually want to hear from you.
Here’s a visual representation of what your re-engagement efforts could look like:
Step 6: Track What Works (and What Doesn’t)
Re-engaging a dormant list isn’t just about sending emails – it’s about learning what resonates with your audience. Keep a close eye on key metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and conversions to see how your campaigns are performing.
Experiment with different elements of your emails to fine-tune your approach. For example, does a playful subject line work better than a formal one? Does a bold CTA button get more clicks than a subtle text link? Even small tweaks can make a big difference.
And if someone still doesn’t respond after several attempts, it’s okay to let them go. Removing unengaged subscribers keeps your list lean, healthy, and effective.
Step 7: Keep the Momentum Going
Once you’ve re-engaged your audience, don’t let them slip away again. Consistency is key.
Set up a regular email schedule so subscribers know when to expect updates. Whether it’s weekly, fortnightly, or monthly, the important thing is to stay top of mind without overwhelming them.
Personalisation also plays a big role in keeping people engaged. Segment your list and tailor your emails based on their preferences, behaviour, or location. For instance, a fitness brand could send urban subscribers offers on high-energy group classes like reformer Pilates or HIIT, while rural subscribers might receive content focused on home workout plans or outdoor fitness routines. To learn more about personalising your email communications, check out our guide to crafting tailored email campaigns that bring great results.
Finally, make your emails worth opening. Exclusive offers, valuable resources, and engaging content ensure your subscribers look forward to hearing from you.
Revitalise Your Email List with Bigg
Re-engaging a dormant email list requires more than just sending a few emails – it’s about understanding your audience, crafting compelling campaigns, and delivering consistent value. At Bigg, we’re experts in email marketing strategy, helping businesses of all sizes and natures reignite their marketing efforts and achieve measurable results.
Our tailored approach ensures that your campaigns resonate with your audience, from re-engagement to long-term retention. Whether you’re a small business or a large enterprise, we’ll work with you to maximise the potential of your email marketing.
Don’t let an inactive list hold your business back. With our expert guidance, you can transform dormant subscribers into loyal customers. Contact us today to get started on making your email marketing as effective as it can be!
Comments are closed.